Tellico Village vs Rarity Bay: An Honest Side-by-Side From Someone Who Sells Both
Quick Answer: If you’re exploring Tellico Village and Rarity Bay 55 Plus Communities in East Tennessee, here’s a comparison of two popular neighborhoods. Tellico Village is a large, open community of roughly 5,000 homes in Loudon County, with three golf courses, five marinas, and a pay-to-play model where nothing is mandatory. Rarity Bay is a smaller, gated peninsula in Vonore, with one golf course, covered boat slips, an equestrian center, and optional club memberships. Same lake, two very different ways to live on it.
Buyers who come to me looking at Tellico Lake almost always end up weighing these two names against each other. It makes sense. Both sit on the same water. Both have golf, boats, and a clubhouse. But they are not two versions of the same thing. They are two different lifestyles, and the right pick has nothing to do with which is “better.” It has to do with how you actually want to live your days.
I sell in both. Here’s the honest breakdown, side by side, so that you can find yourself in it.
Prefer to watch instead of read? I walk through the whole comparison in the video below, then everything is written out underneath.
Tellico Village vs Rarity Bay at a glance
| Tellico Village Rarity | y Bay | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Loudon, TN (Loudon County) | Vonore, TN (Monroe County) |
| Size | ~4,900 acres, ~5,000 homes, ~8,000 residents | ~960-acre peninsula, ~600 homes now (~1,000 at build-out) |
| Gated? | No – open, public roads | Yes – gated |
| Cost model | Pay-to-play – no mandatory golf or club dues | Optional social + golf memberships (separate fees) |
| Golf | Three courses: Toqua, Tanasi, The Links at Kahite | One course |
| Marinas | Five community marinas | Marina, with covered boat slips |
| Homes | From ~$400k; sweet spot $500k-$700k; lakefront $1.5M+ | Sweet spot $600k-$900k; lake-view $1M-$1.5M; lakefront $1.5M-$2M+ |
| Building lots | Nearly sold out, a few left | Plenty available, no build-timeframe requirement |
| Architecture | Wide mix across eight villages | Cohesive French Country theme |
| Horses | No equestrian facilities | Equestrian center, 100+ acres of trails |
| Golf carts | Mostly a car community (Kahite is the exception) | Cart is everyday transportation |
| Clubs | 200+ clubs and organizations | About 70 clubs |
Now the detail behind the table.
Size and feel: a small city vs a small town
Tellico Village is big. About 4,900 acres, close to 5,000 homes, roughly 8,000 people, spread across eight named villages. That scale is the whole point for a lot of buyers. It means variety – in home styles, in price, in the kind of street you land on. It means you can show up knowing nobody and find your people fast, because there is always something starting up.
Rarity Bay is the opposite kind of good. It’s a single gated peninsula, right next door, with about 450 homes today and room for roughly 1,000 once it’s fully built out. You will know your neighbors by name inside a month. That’s not a slogan; it’s just what happens in a community that size. If a large place has ever felt like too much to you, Rarity Bay is going to feel like a relief.
Reality Check: Neither is better. They’re different. Some people find a 5,000-home community energizing and a 450-home community small. Others find the big one exhausting and the small one like home. Be honest with yourself about which one you are before you fall for a house.
There’s a practical side to the size difference too, and it matters more to out-of-state buyers than they expect. The Village is bigger and more built up, and it has Summit Medical right on site, so a doctor and the day-to-day stuff are close. Rarity Bay is more rural, which is exactly why some people love it, but it does put you a little farther from services. Both are a manageable drive to Knoxville and McGhee Tyson Airport, which is the question I get from nearly every buyer flying in from out of state.
The gate, the county, and the taxes
Tellico Village is open. Public roads run through it, and there’s no gate or guardhouse. Plenty of people love that – it feels like a real town, not a compound. If a controlled entrance matters to you, though, that’s a mark against it.
Rarity Bay is gated, and for a lot of buyers that’s the draw. There’s a real sense of arrival and a little more privacy. I’ve written before about the everyday benefits of a gated community like Rarity Bay if that’s high on your list.
Here’s a detail most comparisons skip: these two are in different counties. Tellico Village is in Loudon County. Rarity Bay is in Vonore, which is Monroe County. Both are in Tennessee, so there’s no state income tax on either side. Property tax rates are set by county, so they aren’t identical, but on both sides they’re low, and low is the word that matters to most of the people I work with. You can check current rates straight from the source at the Loudon County Trustee and the Monroe County Trustee, and I’ll help you compare your numbers against theirs.
Let me put real numbers on it. A few years back I had a client from Buffalo who sold their home up there for $600,000. They came down here and bought in that same price range. In Buffalo, the property tax on their old home ran about $25,000 a year. The home I sold them here runs about $1,900 a year. That’s a heck of a pay raise, just on property taxes alone. That’s the math that makes people from New York, the New England states, and Illinois stop and take a hard look at Tellico Lake.
Pro Tip: Bring your current property tax bill when we talk. The tax swing between a high-tax state and either of these communities is often the single biggest number in the whole decision, and most people underestimate it until they see their own bill next to what they’d pay here.
What it costs to belong: pay-to-play vs memberships
This is the difference the other comparisons leave out, and it’s a big one.
Tellico Village runs on a pay-to-play model. You only pay for what you actually use. There are no mandatory golf memberships and no forced membership fees. If you don’t golf, you don’t pay for golf. There’s even a yacht club, and it costs nothing to belong. You can eat there anytime you want. Base POA dues run about $187 a month, and that covers the core amenities everyone shares. Everything past that is your call. For a lot of buyers, that “nothing is mandatory” structure is the single most underrated thing about the Village. It’s why the place feels affordable to live in, not just to buy into.
Rarity Bay works differently. The clubhouse, the fitness facility, and the golf course are there, but you pay for the ones you want. There’s a social membership fee, and a separate membership fee to join the golf course. That’s not a downside; it’s a country-club structure, and some buyers prefer it – they want the club, and they’re happy to pay for it. In Rarity Bay, you’ve also got HOA dues on top of any memberships you choose. Just go in knowing the ongoing cost of belonging is part of the picture in Rarity Bay in a way it isn’t in the Village. Pencil out the full monthly number before you fall for a home, not after.
Golf: three courses vs one
If golf is central to your week, this is a real fork in the road.
Tellico Village has three 18-hole courses – Toqua, Tanasi, and The Links at Kahite. Three different layouts, three different moods, and you can play a fresh one whenever you feel like it. If you’d get restless on the same course all year, that variety is worth a lot. Here’s my rundown of all three Tellico Village courses.
Local Note: You’ll sometimes see other sites list “Chota” as a Tellico Village golf course. Chota is a village and a rec center, not a course. The three courses are Toqua, Tanasi, and The Links at Kahite. If a comparison gets that wrong, it’s worth asking what else it got wrong.
Rarity Bay has one course, and that’s not a knock. A single course means a tighter membership and a more private-club feel – you see the same faces, the pro knows your game, it becomes your course. Some golfers want exactly that over endless variety. I broke down Rarity Bay’s course against Tanasi if you want to compare them head-to-head.
Water and boats: more slips vs covered slips
Both communities put you on Tellico Lake with lakefront homes and slip access, and both have detached marinas.
Tellico Village has five community marinas, so there’s more slip inventory overall. The catch, and I’ll always tell you this straight, is that demand runs ahead of supply and a slip can mean a waitlist. If a boat is the reason you’re moving here, we plan for that early – sometimes by targeting a home that already has a private dock. It’s worth understanding the tradeoffs of a leased slip versus a private dock before you commit.
Rarity Bay has its own marina, and here’s the differentiator: it has covered boat slips. If keeping your boat out of the sun and weather matters to you, that’s a real point in Rarity Bay’s favor over the Village: fewer boats, simpler scene, same great water.
Homes, prices, and the sweet spot
Homes in Tellico Village start around $400,000 and go up from there. The sweet spot, the range where most of my buyers land, is $500,000 to $700,000. In that range, you’re looking at around 2,000 square feet, three bedrooms, two and a half baths. That same home is tough to find in Rarity Bay, where prices run a notch higher.
Rarity Bay’s sweet spot sits around $600,000 to $900,000. Part of that is the gated, smaller-inventory premium, and part is the look. Rarity Bay leans into a cohesive French Country style, so the community reads as one intentional place rather than a mix of eras. If that curated feel speaks to you, it’s a genuine plus.
Rarity Bay is also where the lake-view homes are. Tellico Village doesn’t have many true lake-view lots, but Rarity Bay’s terrain gives you homes looking out over both the water and the mountains, generally around $1,000,000 to $1,500,000. Lakefront in Rarity Bay runs $1,500,000 to $2,000,000 and up, similar to lakefront in the Village.
If you want to build, that’s where these two really split right now. Tellico Village is nearly sold out on lots 308 okthere are a few left for someone determined to build, but not many. Rarity Bay has plenty of lots, with no build-timeframe requirement, so you can buy the land now and build when you’re ready instead of on someone else’s clock. Start with my guide to finding the right lot and building in Rarity Bay.
What Most Buyers Miss: The most common worry I hear about building is “how do I do this when I don’t even live here yet?” You don’t have to be here. I work with a local builder who’s built for many of my out-of-state clients, and he’s good at keeping remote buyers in the loop through the whole process. Building from another state is normal here, not the exception.
A word on resale, because you should think about the exit before the entrance
Nobody in these comparisons talks about selling, and they should. You’re buying a home, but you’re also buying into a resale market, and the two communities behave differently when it’s time to move on.
Tellico Village has thousands of homes and a steady stream of buyers looking at it every month. More comparable sales, more traffic, more ways to price it right. That usually means a more liquid market and a faster sale when you decide to move.
Rarity Bay is a smaller, more exclusive market. Fewer homes trade hands, so it can take a little longer to find the right buyer, but the same scarcity that makes it feel special is part of what protects the value. Neither is a problem. They’re just different exits, and knowing that going in beats learning it the hard way three years from now.
Daily life: carts, horses, and how you’ll actually spend a Tuesday
This is where the two really part ways.
In Rarity Bay, a golf cart is real transportation. People run to the clubhouse, the marina, a neighbor’s driveway on a cart. It’s part of the rhythm of the place. Rarity Bay also has something Tellico Village doesn’t: a full equestrian center with more than 100 acres of riding trails. If horses are in your life, or you’ve always wanted them to be, that’s not a small thing – it’s the whole reason some buyers choose Rarity Bay. Rarity Bay has around 70 clubs of its own, so there’s plenty to do inside a smaller, closer circle.
Tellico Village is bigger and more spread out, so most getting-around there happens by car. The exception is Kahite, the Village’s southern section, which is more rural and has its own true golf-cart culture. What Tellico Village offers instead is sheer volume. There are over 200 clubs and organizations. Whatever you’re into – hiking, pickleball, woodworking, theater, dragon boats – it already exists, with a group that meets. Newcomers usually land through the New Villagers club, which exists to plug you into the clubs and people that match your interests. It’s how you meet folks fast.
What Most Buyers Miss: The “200+ clubs” number and the “everybody knows your name” feeling are a tradeoff, not a package deal. The bigger the community, the more there is to do, and the longer it takes to feel known. The smaller one flips that. Pick the side of that tradeoff you actually want.
Here’s an insider tip I give people who get stuck between these two. If you love that the Village has no mandatory fees but you keep coming back to Rarity Bay’s cart-and-country feel, look at Kahite. It’s part of Tellico Village, so it runs on the Village’s pay-to-play model, but it’s more rural, and it’s a true golf-cart community with its own course, clubhouse, and pub. For a certain buyer, Kahite is the bridge between the two.
Local Note: These two communities are friendly rivals, not strangers. Every year their golfers square off in the Tellico Village versus Rarity Bay Challenge Cup. Wherever you land, you’re never far from the other one, so you don’t lose access to a single thing the other community offers. You’re choosing where you sleep, not which half of the lake you’re allowed to enjoy.
So which one fits you?
Here’s how I’d sort it if you were sitting across from me.
Lean Tellico Village if you want an active lifestyle, variety, a wide range of prices, three golf courses, more marinas, a pay-to-play cost structure, and a packed calendar you could never get through. If you’re relocating from a busy place and you want that energy again, this is usually the one. Read more on what retiring to Tellico Village really looks like.
Lean Rarity Bay if you want a gate, a smaller and more private community, a country-club feel, covered boat slips, lake-and-mountain views, horses and trails, and a place where a golf cart gets you most of where you’re going. If big communities have worn you out before, this will feel right.
Now the part most agents won’t say out loud. Here’s who should skip each one.
Skip Tellico Village if you need a gate to feel at home, if a big open community feels like too much, or if a country-club structure with covered slips and horses is the whole reason you’re moving to a lake in the first place.
Skip Rarity Bay if you want the lowest entry price, if you’d resent paying a social or golf membership on top of HOA dues, if you want three courses to rotate through, or if you’d rather be a few minutes closer to a hospital and a full grocery run.
Same lake. Two honest answers. The only wrong move is choosing before you’ve stood in both.
Common Questions
Is Tellico Village or Rarity Bay a 55+ or age-restricted community?
Neither has a hard age requirement to buy. Both draw heavily from retirees and 55+ buyers relocating from out of state, so the feel skews that way, but you don’t have to be a certain age to purchase in either one. If a true age-restricted community is what you’re after, that’s a different conversation, and I can walk you through the real options.
Do I have to pay golf or club membership fees in either community?
In Tellico Village, no. It runs on a pay-to-play model, so there are no mandatory golf or club memberships – you only pay for what you use, and even the yacht club is free to join. Rarity Bay is set up more like a country club, with a social membership fee and a separate golf membership fee for those who want them. Neither approach is wrong, but the ongoing cost of belonging is higher in Rarity Bay.
How many golf courses does each community have?
Tellico Village has three 18-hole courses: Toqua, Tanasi, and The Links at Kahite. Rarity Bay has one. If playing a different course each week matters, Tellico Village wins on variety. If you’d rather have one home course and a private-club feel, Rarity Bay’s single course is a strength, not a shortfall.
Is Rarity Bay or Tellico Village more expensive?
Tellico Village has the lower entry point, starting around $400,000, with most buyers landing between $500,000 and $700,000. Rarity Bay generally runs higher, with a sweet spot around $600,000 to $900,000, reflecting its gated, smaller-inventory character. Lakefront on both sides runs past $1.5M. The right budget answer depends on the specific home, not just the community.
Are Tellico Village and Rarity Bay in the same county?
No. Tellico Village is in Loudon County and Rarity Bay is in Vonore, in Monroe County. Both are in Tennessee with no state income tax, but property tax rates are set at the county level, so they differ slightly. Both are low compared to what most out-of-state buyers are used to paying.
Which community is better for resale?
They behave differently, and neither is a problem. Tellico Village has thousands of homes and steady buyer traffic, which usually means a more liquid market and a quicker sale. Rarity Bay is a smaller, more exclusive market, so it can take a little longer to find the right buyer, but that same scarcity helps protect the value. Think about your exit before you buy, not after.
How far are Tellico Village and Rarity Bay from Knoxville and the airport?
Both are a manageable drive to Knoxville and McGhee Tyson Airport, which makes them easy for family and for buyers flying in from out of state. The bigger day-to-day difference is services. Tellico Village has Summit Medical on site and more shopping close by, while Rarity Bay is more rural and a bit farther from the nearest full grocery run.
The bottom line
Tellico Village and Rarity Bay are both terrific, and neither one is the “right” answer on paper. Tellico Village is the big, open, active, do-everything community where nothing is mandatory. Rarity Bay is the gated, close-knit, country-club community with horses, covered slips, and mountain views. The one that fits you is the one that matches how you want your ordinary days to feel.
I sell in both, so I’ve got no reason to push you one way or the other – only to help you get it right the first time. If you’ve got questions, let’s set up a discovery call and talk them through. And if you really want to know, come experience it on a discovery tour and stand in both communities yourself. Call me at 865-696-9002 or start at tellicolakehometeam.com. I’m here to help.

